Sacral Nutation: The Key to Straight Feet in Backbends

By Monica Gauci

Sacrum Fig 1

Fig 1. Sacral nutation (nodding) between the two pelvic halves (ilia).

There are countless miracles happening in our physical bodies every moment of our existence. One that continues to intrigue me is the symphony of cranial motion that happens with our every breath! This motion is synchronised with another gentle movement at our sacrum as it rocks between the two pelvic halves or ilia. Cranial-sacral motion is constant and rhythmical as it circulates the vital fluid that our brain produces – cerebrospinal fluid or CSF. CSF nourishes and protects our nervous system, transports important hormones from the pituitary gland and maintains central nervous system homeostasis.

Although the motion at the sacrum when we breathe happens involuntarily as a micro-movement, we can also exaggerate this movement in our posture. This specialised movement pattern is termed nutation and counter-nutation. Nutation comes from the Latin word nutare, which means to nod, analogous to nodding the head. Although there are different theories on the exact axis and movement of the sacrum, the classic theory of Farabeuf is that in nutation the sacral promontory (the upper most part of the sacrum where it joins the spine) ‘nods’ or drops forward (anterior) and down (inferior), while the coccyx or tailbone moves posterior and superior (see figure 1). Counter-nutation is simply the opposite movement.

Posturally, nutation and counter-nutation of the sacrum spontaneously happen as our body adapts to its natural demands and surroundings. Living on a steep mountain I notice how naturally the position of my sacrum, pelvis and spine shift to change my centre of gravity. When ascending the steep slopes my sacrum moves forward into nutation, my pelvis also tips forward and my spine arches towards the ground. Descending the mountain, the opposite happens: my sacrum tilts back into counter-nutation, my pelvis shifts back and my whole spine curves backward pulling me in closer towards the slope. These same sacral movements participate in the physiology of labour and childbirth. The sacrum counter-nutates to increase the dimensions of the pelvic inlet encouraging the descent of the baby’s head into the pelvis and then tilts forward into nutation to increase the aperture of the pelvic outlet, facilitating delivery of the newborn.

Sacral Versus Pelvic Movement

It is important to understand that movement of the sacrum and movement of the whole pelvis are different phenomena. Sacral movement happens in relation to the pelvis or ilia. When the sacrum moves anterior into nutation, relatively, the ilia move posterior. This means that the entire pelvis can be flexed forward, as in a forward bend, and the sacrum can be either nutated or counter-nutated in this position. The same applies when the pelvis is extended back as in a back bend. Try this: make a fist with one hand. This hand will represent our sacrum. Cup the palm of your opposite hand up against the thumb side of your fist. This hand represents one ilium (see figure 2).

Fig.2 With your fist as your sacrum and your other hand as one ilium, roll your fist forward. Feel how the sacrum fist moves forward in relation to the ilium hand.

As you move your fist forward into nutation, feel how it rotates in relation to the hand it articulates with. Relative to the sacral fist, the ilium hand moves posterior. This coordinated movement between the sacrum and ilia happens naturally and is not something that we can manipulate. If the sacrum is not able to float and move freely between the two ilia, normal sacroiliac movement cannot happen. This leads to dysfunction and a whole cascade of compensatory adaptations.

Kinematic Chain

More important than sacral nutation itself is the effect this movement has on the spine, the pelvis and the limbs. When the sacrum tips forward into nutation the lumbar lordosis (natural curve in the low back) is increased and the entire spine unravels and lengthens. Additionally, the rib cage lifts and opens. In Yoga, nutation of the sacrum may seem paradoxical in that it can be applied to both forward and back bending. It is this elongation of the spine that is complimentary to both groups of postures. Sacral nutation enables us to freely lengthen our spine and open our chest and heart energy centre or chakra.

Conversely, when we counter-nutate the sacrum by tipping its base posteriorly and tucking the coccyx under, the low back or lumbar curve flattens and the chest compresses as the rib cage is anchored down. Counter-nutation has a stabilising effect on the entire axial column. It is helpful in most of the yoga standing postures, arm-balances, inversions and leg-behind-head postures. Counter-nutation of the sacrum in back bends makes it difficult to arch the lumbar spine and open the heart area. This method is sometimes taught to beginners to yoga to protect the low back as it greatly inhibits extension of the lumbar spine. However, extension of the spine will then be forced into the lower lumbar vertebrae, especially where the lumbar spine meets the sacrum (L5/S1).

Let’s look what happens at the pelvis during nutation and counter-nutation. The sacroiliac (SI) joints are not parallel to each other but lie at a 45-degree angle. This means that as the sacrum nods forward into nutation, the wings of the ilia move towards each other (medially) in the front of the pelvis. Correspondingly, the ischial tuberosities or sit bones move apart (see figure 3). In fact, this is one of the easiest ways to access the movement of sacral nutation. The common instruction given in yoga classes to initiate sacral nutation is to broaden or “flare the sit bones”.  In counter-nutation the opposite happens, the sit bones draw toward each other and the iliac wings flare open in the front of the pelvis.

Key to Straight Feet in Back Bends

What has not yet been described in texts on Yoga Anatomy is what happens to our lower limbs during sacral nutation and counter-nutation. As our thighbones or femur are connected to the pelvis at the hip joint (acetabulofemoral joint), this movement of the pelvis during sacral nutation translates into medial or internal rotation of the legs. In this way sacral nutation is not only a liberating technique to arching backward, it is also the key to keeping your feet straight in backbends! Contrary to this, if the sacrum is counter-nutated in a back bend the thighs will tend to externally rotate as the iliac wings move towards the back of the body (see figure 3). This translates into turning the feet out in back bends.

Fig.3 As the sacrum nutates, the iliac wings roll in toward each other, the ischial tuberosities draw apart and the femur internally rotate.

Fig.3 As the sacrum nutates, the iliac wings roll in toward each other, the ischial tuberosities draw apart and the femur internally rotate.

This kinematic chain or reciprocal movement pattern in the spine, the pelvis and the legs are best assessed from an all-fours position. From all-fours, without tipping the pelvis forward or backward, try broadening the sit bones. Notice the natural exaggerated curve that happens in the low back. This corresponds to the psoas muscle pulling the sacrum forward into nutation. The psoas attaches to all the lumbar vertebrae and transverses the SI joint as it reaches down through the pelvis to attach at the lesser trochanter at the proximal end of the femur. Feel how your chest freely opens and lifts. And now feel the internal rotation that happens in your legs without any concentrated effort or muscle engagement. This is how nutation of the sacrum enables us to keep the feet straight in back bends.

In my last article, ‘Glute Max for Maximum Extension’, I described the importance of using the gluteus maximus muscle when performing backbends. Back bending is a complex movement pattern. Written ‘asana workshops’ are often limited by the burden of the copious amount of text needed to describe a posture and are thereby often incomplete. If sacral nutation is not adopted as a preparation for backbends, the posterior pelvic tilt generated by the engagement of glute max will often find students counter-nutating their sacrum. This is the reason that students sometimes report that relaxation of their glute max relieves discomfort in backbends. Not engaging glute max in backbends, however, leaves the fulcrum of the backward arch in the lumbar spine instead of at the hip joint. This brings me back to my walking uphill analogy: it is my gluteus maximus muscle that powerfully propels me up the slopes! To not use glute max in back bends can cause excessive wear and tear on the already inherently mobile joints of the lumbar spine.

Sacral Nutation in Back Bends

So let’s look at accessing sacral nutation in backbends. Because of the reciprocal movement cascade between the sacrum, pelvis and femur we can access sacral nutation via any of these different movements. For most people, it is difficult to isolate movement of the sacrum itself. An easier way to access sacral nutation in back bends, is to already put a back bend in your spine by arching the lumbar spine and lifting and opening the heart area. This setup will transform ease into strenuous back bends such as Purvottanasana. Now activate the posterior fascial chain by engaging the hamstring and glute max muscles.

An alternative to accessing sacral nutation is to spread or widen your sit bones. If your feet are grounded you can also induce this movement at the sit bones, via the long lever of your legs, with the action of drawing the feet apart without actually moving them. This action is termed abduction and engages the tensor fascia latae muscle, which also internally or medially rotates the legs. Some teachers will also instruct students to draw their legs together in the opposite action of adduction whilst drawing the upper thighs back toward the coccyx. This action has a similar effect by engaging the other medial rotator muscles of the hip joint, the anterior portion of adductor magnus and the gracilis. In this way sacral nutation is accessed by actively internally rotating the legs.

Sacral Nutation in Other Postures

Let’s look at the effects of sacral nutation in other postures. The easiest postures to access sacral nutation are the wide-legged forward bends, e.g., Prasarita Padottanasana. With the legs abducted (apart) the sit bones freely broaden as the sacrum tips forward into nutation. You have probably noticed that the feet will often excessively inwardly rotate in this posture. This is a result of the natural reciprocal internal rotation of the legs as the sacrum nutates and the pelvic halves move medially. In contrast, in standing postures like Trikonasana and Parshvakonasana where the sacrum is counter-nutated, this sacral positioning compliments the external rotation of the legs needed here to open the hip joints. This same movement pattern occurs in leg-behind-head postures.

The Brakes of Sacral Motion

Why is it easy for some to access sacral movement and more difficult for others? Movement at the sacroiliac joints is small (5 to 10 degrees) and varies between individuals and circumstances. The sacrum is suspended between the ilia by strong articular ligaments. It is these ligaments that stabilise the SI joints and determine how much sacral movement is possible (see figures 4a and 4b). The very strong interosseous or axial ligament acts as the fulcrum for sacral nutation whilst the other numerous sacral ligaments act as brakes. Generally speaking, sacral movement will be easier in flexible females (eg, during labour!) and more difficult in stiff males. Additionally, females may notice an increase in flexibility around menstruation and ovulation as the spike of hormones at these times increase the pliability of their ligaments. For this reason excessive nutation in counter indicated in those with hypermobility and in pre and postnatal women. These students will often get relief of their SI joint, sacrum or low back discomfort by either externally rotating their legs or drawing the sit bones together, leading to a more stabilised counter-nutated sacrum.

If you’ve read my previous articles: ‘What’s Functional in Yoga’ and ‘Glute Max for Maximum Extension’ you will know that how I perform and teach Yoga is very much based on the body’s natural movement patterns. Ultimately, if you wish to practice yoga for the rest of your life, what you do and how you move must be in harmony with the way Nature has designed us. It cannot come from our head, our ideas or concepts or even our most well intended ideals.

monicaAuthor: Monica Gauci

View Profile

Visit Monica’s Website: http://www.8limbs.com

 

 

 References

Coulter, H. D. Anatomy of Hatha Yoga. Honesdale: Body and Breath, 2001.

DeJanette, M. Sacro-Occipital Technique Craniotherapy Manual. S.O.T.O. Australasia, Queensland.

Kapandji, A. I. The Physiology of the Joints, vol 3, 6th ed. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingston, 2008.

Sutherland, William Garner. Osteopathy in the Cranial Field. Harold Ives Magoun, Denver. 1951.

Walker, Joan M. Physical Therapy. The Sacroiliac Joint: a critical review. Dec 1992.

Muscle images taken from visible body 3D Muscle Premium, www.visiblebody.com

Other articles by Monica that you might find interesting:
  • Putting the Curve Back in Your Neck, Saving Your Neck – Part 3 March 29, 2015 Although we usually think and talk about muscles as being weak or strong, closer to the truth is that muscles are usually inhibited or facilitated, respectively. Inhibition is when neural input (from our nervous system) to the muscle has been down-regulated. Facilitation is the opposite, when neural input to a muscle is excessive or up-regulated. ...
  • You Were Born to Gaze at the Stars, Saving Your Neck – Part 2 March 29, 2015 In Part 1 we looked at some of the biomechanics of neck problems and especially how to eliminate unnecessary tension in our neck when weight-bearing on our hands. In yoga asanas we commonly take our head back, extending our head and neck. Students are often cautious and hold back with this movement, concerned that it ...
  • What’s the Problem with Your Shoulder? April 18, 2016 Our shoulder is a precision instrument that simultaneously has a vast scope in its range of motion. With pinpoint precision we can synchronise our shoulder muscles to maneuver our arm to point our finger precisely at our object of choice – an action that requires the coordinated recruitment of numerous muscles that surround our shoulder ...
  • Yoga and Aging March 13, 2016 When I was young and naïve I used to say “the good thing about practicing yoga is that as you get older you only get stronger and more flexible!” This is true up to a point and that point is different for every body. The fact is that as we age our body slows down. ...
  • Yoga Therapy for Hamstring Injuries April 28, 2015 If you’ve ever had an injury at your hamstring injury, you will know about it! You’ll go from comfortable forward bending one day to dramatically restricted, often painful forward bends the next day. This injury occurs where the tendon of the hamstring muscle knits into the membranous lining of the bone, the periosteum. In this ...
  • The Role of the Adductors in Backbends September 15, 2015 Many yoga practitioners instinctually know to engage their inner thigh muscles (adductors) in backbends to prevent their knees from falling out to the sides. Let’s examine how we can utilise this action to ignite our core, expand our backward arch and experience simultaneously more stability and spaciousness in backbends. The adductor muscles of the inner thigh ...
  • Saving Your Neck, Understanding the Biomechanics of Neck Problems – Part 1 March 29, 2015 Our necks are one of the most vulnerable parts of our body and once we have a neck problem they can be complex to resolve. There are a few reasons why the neck cops the brunt of it. Firstly the neck or cervical spine has the greatest range of movement possible in the entire spine. This ...
  • What Is ‘Functional’ in Yoga? June 11, 2013 By Dr Monica Gauci Funcitonal is the buzz word at the moment in the exercise, movement and especially the physical rehabilitation scene. Movements or exercises are considered ‘functional’ if they support the movement patterns that are necessary for us to function in our daily lives. There are seven primal, functional movement patterns: bending, squatting, lunging, twisting, ...
  • Opening the Heart April 8, 2013 By Dr Monica Gauci In a yoga practice much emphasis is placed on opening the heart. Opening the heart has physical, emotional, psychological and spiritual benefits. Rounded shoulders and a hunched spine are typically associated as the posture of someone who is less confident, timid, fearful or possibly depressed. We round our shoulders and stoop forward to ...
  • Glute Max for Maximum Extension August 24, 2013 By Dr Monica Gauci For some the jury is still not out on whether one should or should not engage the gluteus maximus muscle when performing back bending yoga postures. Firstly, let’s have a close look at the functional anatomy of this muscle. Gluteus maximus, commonly known as glute max, is the superficial ‘rump’ muscle of our ...

You may also like...

9 Responses

  1. John says:

    How much does the sacrum move?

  2. Thierry says:

    Thanks for your writting.
    Which are , appart of the gluteus maxi the muscles involving in the Nutation and the contre nutation?
    Have a luminous day.
    Thierry

  3. Monica Gauci says:

    Dear Thierry
    Nutation is initiated by the lower fibres of psoas major. Counter-nutation is initiated by the pelvic floor muscles. If you allow glute max to posteriorly tilt the pelvis the sacrum will go into counter-nutation. Hope that helps…
    Namaste
    Monica

  4. Meghan says:

    What is happening at the SI in lunge postures (crescent)?

  5. Monica Gauci says:

    Hi Meghan.

    If you mean Virabhadrasana, one leg is flexed at the hip, the other extended. For both of these movements the sacrum will want to nutate, however, remember that the sacrum can move on all planes. Nutation and counter-nutation only describe its movement on the sagittal plane.

    Also you can still engage the glutes to work this pose effectively. Allow the sacrum to nutate so the spine can unravel and the glutes and other hip extensors will have you hover in the pose!

    Namaste
    Monica

  6. laurieboyle says:

    did you find the coccyx to be moving separately from the sacrum during cranial flexion? and where did you find the reference? thank you!! LaurieBoyle

    • Monica Gauci says:

      Hi Laurie. As the coccyx is fused to the sacrum (the individual vertebrae of the sacrum fuse by 6 years of age so probably by then) yes it will move where the sacrum goes. The reference is from DeJanette (above) and I think you would find the same information from a list of Osteopaths who specialise in CranioSacral therapy.
      Hope that helps.
      Namaste
      Monica

  7. Dave says:

    Hi, Thank you for all your information. All the articles here have been very helpful.
    I have recently started a backbend posture that is new to me, Sirsa Padasana. Which is Sirsasana with a backbend and the feet are brought down towards the head.
    I have found it quite challenging since my feet are not connected to anything, the ground, to apply force to the hips. My feet don’t reach my head. I have found squeezing my feet together is helpful but my pose needs some work. I am attempting to even out the backbend since it seems to dump right to the lumbar spine. Do you have any helpful tips for this pose?

    I have practiced Vrscikasana 1, Scorpion on the forearms for a long time but I find the two poses very different. My feet don’t touch my head it this pose either. I didn’t really squeeze my feet together in Scorpion but I have started and that is nice improvement. I have no idea how to find a teacher to help me with this so I am kind of on my own. Also I have a very strong but very inflexible back.

Leave a Reply

Error: Please enter a valid email address

Error: Invalid email

Error: Please enter your first name

Error: Please enter your last name

Error: Please enter a username

Error: Please enter a password

Error: Please confirm your password

Error: Password and password confirmation do not match