Sitting for Meditation

By David Keil

The basic goal of all the asana practice is finding and maintaining a comfortable padmasana (lotus pose) for meditation. There are a few key anatomical components and principles to finding this comfort. The foundation of the pose is the crossing of the legs and “sit bones” comfortably on the floor. With a firm foundation we find an upward energy and lift in the spine, which eventually becomes effortless.

Sitting in Padmasana

Finding your padmasana, much less a comfortable one is a difficulty for many people who practice yoga and meditation. It is difficult to quiet the mind when the knee, hips, back or neck are uncomfortable. Why is it so difficult? What is it that we’re actually doing to our hips, knees and back anyway? What can I do to prepare my body for practices that require this posture?

All questions we’ve asked our teachers or ourselves from time to time. You must understand that yoga (coming from India) practically assumes that one can do lotus. On my trips to India I’ve observed young and old regularly sitting on the floor in lotus, half lotus or squatting. This lends itself to knees and hips that are ready and available for being crossed fully. Yoga is from a different place. On the contrary are our chairs, desks, cars and our “modern” culture that discourage something as simple as sitting on the floor.

So, what to do? By understanding the basic function of a couple of joints you may be able to save yourself some pain in the leg as well as the uh… back. We’ll hopefully get to do a more focused hip and knee article later on but for the moment let’s look at some basics around these joints.

There are three main joints in the leg, the ankle, knee and hip. They function together and movement at one often requires movement at another. The knee is at the center of this interconnected chain and therefore regulates the function of the leg as a whole. If the hip or ankles are tight, the force that is created in the leg often finds its way to the knee possibly leading to meniscus tears, or general pain and achiness. We can also use the functioning of the knee to help us focus and isolate the other joints, particularly the hip in lotus.

From dandasana bring your hands together in front of you with palms open and facing upward. Let your leg lift leg and place your foot/ankle into the palm of your hands (lower your hands and move them forward if needed). Now, relax your hip joint and allow your knee to slowly lower. A very important action happens as you do this, and that action is an outward or external rotation of your lower leg (shin/calf), which means your upper leg (thigh) has rotated outward as well. You may even need to exaggerate this action if you feel a pinching on the inside or outside of your knee by lifting your calf muscles out of the way as you flex (bend) your knee. Draw your heel towards your navel and take half lotus.

In any lotus type position, if you feel an excessive amount of pinching or pain simply lift your knee up toward the ceiling and you’ll find the pain disappears. This is indicative of the force created by a tight hip joint being relieved.

  • Developmental poses
  • Baddha konasana
  • Squatting
  • Virasana

Upward and Onward

It may take some time to create a stable base for the spine to sit on in a lotus position. All seated poses rely on the “sit-bones” for foundation. These large boney areas are actually called the ischial tuberosities and are the inferior (lower) and posterior (back) part of the pelvis. The pelvic bowl has a major influence on the spine above it as it is connected to the sacrum (via the sacroiliac joint), which is base of the spine.

The pelvis is doing an anterior tilt when the pubic bone in the front heads down toward the floor. The pelvis is doing a posterior tilt when the pubic bone comes upward toward the ribs. If the hip joint and associated hamstring muscles on the back of the thigh are tight, when we sit on the floor our pelvis is pulled into a posterior tilt. If the hamstrings are looser then we find an anterior tilt or a neutral position coming more easily.

The tilts of the pelvis are also associated with the curve in our lower back (lumbar spine). An anterior tilt increases or exaggerates this curve in the lumbar and a posterior tilt reduces the curve in the lumbar spine. Over a long period of time the removal of this curve can be detrimental to the integrity of the entire spine and particularly to those very important and needed discs in the lumbar vertebrae which are the most common to dysfunction. Sitting in a car, office seat, or regular chair almost always removes the lumbar curve from our spine and is associated with a posterior tilt. Check yours now and see for yourself.

The effect of the loss of curve in the lumbar reduces the integrity and stamina of the muscle of the back and will affect the spine above. If in a seated position your pelvis is free to tilt forward in an anterior tilt, the lumbar curve is present you’ll find a natural and comfortable energy that helps the rest of the spine above be comfortable for a longer sitting period. This is the reason for a small blanket or bolster under our sit-bones for meditation.

All asanas require a strong and stable foundation. Padmasana starts with the sit-bones on the floor and the legs comfortably crossed. With this foundation the spine comes to its natural alignment more easily and helps increase comfort as well as the movement of prana through a nice and easy breath. Take some time in the evening to do what I refer to as “homework” poses. Try virasana, baddha konsana, and a nice deep squat.

With the right preparation and some regularity of practice of the aforementioned “homework” poses you’ll find more openness in the joints of the leg, a comfortable lotus and the ability to sit for much longer with more comfort for the ultimate yoga practice, meditation!
david keil

Author: David Keil

View Profile

Visit David’s Website:
[/su_column] [/su_row]

If you found this article helpful you might also like this one: Sitbone Pain from Yoga Asana

Click this photo.

Take a look at the Interview I did with David recently when he was at Purple Valley in Goa, India.
Here are some of the articles posted here by David Keil:
  • Sun Salutations Part 1 October 20, 2014 There is nothing that seems to cross all boundaries of yoga styles as clearly as sun salutations. Of course there are variations on the theme, but it seems that all styles do them. Sun Salutations put movement through all of the joints of the body and moves it in many directions. Perhaps we have a ...
  • Your Shoulders in Upward Facing Dog March 30, 2013 By David Keil This is a play off an article I wrote for the newsletter back in May. That one was titled Your Shoulders in Downward Facing Dog. There are perhaps as many variations in what we are told to do with our shoulders in Up Dog and it is sometimes just as confusing for students. As ...
  • How to get some hight in Nakrasana December 21, 2014 20December 2014: Interviewee: David Keil I had the great pleasure recently to be invited to practice with David at the beautiful Purple Valley in Goa. Of course I took the opportunity to make another interview, which is in editing at the moment. In the meantime here is a little clip to help if your Nakrasana looks ...
  • Yes, you can get injured doing a headstand… May 30, 2013 By David Keil Yes, you can get injured doing a headstand… especially if you take the name literally. We can often gather information from the name of a posture. Sometimes embrace the quality or energy of the name, like Virabadrasana (Warrior). Sometimes the name is exactly what we should be doing. Shoulderstand comes to mind. It’s not ...
  • Is Your Hip “Pinching” in a Twist? March 30, 2013 By David Keil This situation can show up in parvrita parsvakonasana, ardha matsayendrasana, marichyasana C, or other twists. The sensation is anything from mild discomfort to an ice pick sensation in the front and inside of the pelvis. The most common description however is that it seems as though something is getting “pinched.” This is a situation ...
  • David Keil Interview 2015 March 6, 2015 When I first started getting into yoga anatomy it was David Keil’s website and videos that I turned to so it is always top of my list to get the chance to sit down and chat with him. Ok so it’s going to be a bit geeky but David always explains things in such an ...
Look at more extracts from David's articles

You may also like...

1 Response

  1. lauren says:

    you do not have to sit in pain! try the MoonLeap Meditation Cushion. It is ergonomically designed to alleviate back pain, and hip, leg and feet numbness and pain. Lets the meditator sit in comfort for longer periods.

Leave a Reply

Error: Please enter a valid email address

Error: Invalid email

Error: Please enter your first name

Error: Please enter your last name

Error: Please enter a username

Error: Please enter a password

Error: Please confirm your password

Error: Password and password confirmation do not match